"
On Intelligence will have a big impact; everyone should read it. In the same way that Erwin Schrödinger's 1943 classic
What is Life? made how molecules store genetic information then the big problem for biology, On Intelligence lays out the framework for understanding the brain."
--James D. Watson, president, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, and Nobel laureate in Physiology
"Brilliant and embued with startling clarity.
On Intelligence is the most important book in neuroscience, psychology, and artificial intelligence in a generation."
--Malcolm Young, neurobiologist and provost, University of Newcastle
"Read this book. Burn all the others. It is original, inventive, and thoughtful, from one of the world's foremost thinkers. Jeff Hawkins will change the way the world thinks about intelligence and the prospect of intelligent machines."
-- John Doerr, partner, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers
Rating 4.5
Good "Popular Science", not a breakthrough
It is pretty clear that there are two classes of reviews for this book. One class, typically written by lay people, believes it to be the best research available on how the human brain truly works. Scientists, however, view the book a bit differently.
I am a researcher in robotics and specialize in developing control systems for autonomous robots. My company builds robots that can move around, and that have arms with which to pick up objects, all working without human control. Vision and touch are the senses used by our machines, combined with biologically inspired computer algorithms, to get the job done. Most of my work, like that of Mr. Hawkins, focuses on thinking about how animal brains might work and applying those thoughts to real systems.
I believe that Mr. Hawkins is a very sharp guy, and he describes his ideas about how the brain works with great clarity. He is outstanding at creating buzz. But, with all due respect, I believe that he doesn't even know what he doesn't know when it comes to building systems that work in the real world. The book reads as if the theories espoused are based on science, but they are really based on the author's conjecture. True, it is reasonable conjecture, but not fact. Software reportedly has been written based on these theories that is capable of recognizing hand drawn objects. I have not found any papers to review concerning this technology, but similar technology (e.g. OCR) is already available that is robust when recognizing hand drawn characters so this is not yet a tremendous breakthrough. Basically, working with 2D images is relatively easy, working with a computer generated 3D world is 10x harder, working with real imagery in a constrained environment (in a lab with controlled lighting, etc.) is 10x harder still, and working outdoors in the real world is about 100x harder than that. Current technology for autonomous robotic control and object recognition is not based on techniques of classical AI, but is in fact based on pattern recognition/matching techniques essentially similar to what Mr. Hawkins proposes, including the idea of prediction.
On the one hand, I applaud the author if this book inspires other people to enter the field. On the other hand, readers are cautioned that this is a "popular science" book and does not represent any great breakthrough.
Thought provoking and truly fascinating.
Jeff Hawkins' day job has been the creation of the Palm Pilot and the Handspring Treo, along with the Grafitti writing system used on those devices. His "hobby" - and a very serious one it seems from this book - is studying how the human brain works.
Hawkins has been bothered by the lack of a unifying theory of what the brain actually does that makes it intelligent and the absense of a good book on the topic for the lay-person. On Intelligence is his response to those concerns. The book is one big hypothesis on what is going on inside all of our heads that separates us from even the fastest computers. The crux of the issue is that our brains are pattern storage and pattern recognition devices that use those two functions to incessantly make predictions about what is coming next in the world around us.
The evidence and explanations that Hawkins offers up are compelling and fascinating and his theory conceptually makes sense when you think about it. In the end Hawkins happily admits - and we as the reader need to remember - that what he is doing is offering up a hypothesis for science to work with, prove and disprove as the study of the human mind advances.
Highly recommended for the interested lay-person by an interested lay-person.
I couldn't recommend a book more highly!!!
I have always been curious about how the brain works, and why it can do things that computers that work a million times faster cannot begin to achieve. I thought this book might be too difficult for me because I am not a scientist, but it was not compicated. It tackles what I used to think must be an infinitely complex subject in a simple and interesting way for the average person, through great writing, common sense explanations and simple analogies. They do an excellent job of avoiding getting into the details that confuse and bore non-scientists. I started reading it out of curiosity, and then I could not put it down. If you have a brain, hope to have a brain someday, or have any interest at all in how brains work, you should read this book!